Benefits of GST in India

The Goods and Services Tax (GST), implemented in India on July 1, 2017, represents one of the most significant reforms in the country’s indirect tax structure. Designed to create a unified tax system, GST has brought numerous advantages to businesses, consumers, and the overall economy. This article outlines the key benefits of GST in India, highlighting its impact on various aspects of the economy and society.

1. Simplification of Tax Structure
GST has simplified India's previously complex tax system by replacing multiple central and state taxes with a single, unified tax:

• Elimination of Multiple Taxes: GST has subsumed numerous taxes, such as Central Excise Duty, Service Tax, VAT, CST, and others, reducing the tax burden on businesses.
• One Nation, One Tax: The introduction of GST has created a common national market by eliminating interstate tax barriers, fostering ease of doing business.

2. Reduction in Cascading Effect of Taxes
One of the most significant advantages of GST is the elimination of the cascading effect (tax on tax):

• Input Tax Credit (ITC): GST allows businesses to claim ITC on the taxes paid on inputs, which can be set off against the GST payable on outputs, thus reducing the overall tax liability.
• Lower Cost of Goods and Services: By reducing the cascading effect, GST has lowered the cost of goods and services, benefiting both businesses and consumers.

3. Increased Transparency and Compliance
GST has brought greater transparency and compliance in the tax system:

• Digital Compliance: The GST regime relies heavily on digital compliance, with taxpayers required to file returns online and maintain digital records, reducing the scope for tax evasion.
• E-Way Bill System: The introduction of the e-Way Bill system for tracking the movement of goods has further enhanced transparency and curbed tax evasion.

4. Boost to Revenue Collection
GST has had a positive impact on government revenue collection:

• Broadening of Tax Base: By bringing more businesses under the tax net, GST has widened the tax base, leading to increased revenue for both central and state governments.
• Improved Tax Administration: The GST system's reliance on technology and self-policing mechanisms has improved tax administration and compliance, contributing to higher revenue collection.

5. Ease of Doing Business
GST has made it easier for businesses to operate in India:

• Simplified Registration and Filing: The introduction of a single, unified tax has simplified the registration and filing process for businesses, reducing administrative burdens.
• Uniform Tax Rates: The uniformity in tax rates across states has eliminated discrepancies and made it easier for businesses to plan their operations and pricing strategies.

6. Encouragement of Make in India Initiative
GST has supported the government's Make in India initiative by promoting manufacturing and exports:

• Reduction in Logistics Costs: The removal of interstate tax barriers and the implementation of the e-Way Bill system have streamlined logistics and reduced transportation costs for manufacturers.
• Boost to Exports: The availability of ITC on inputs used for exports has made Indian goods more competitive in the global market by reducing the tax burden on exporters.

7. Increased Consumer Welfare
Consumers have benefited from GST in several ways:

• Reduction in Prices: The elimination of the cascading effect and the reduction in logistics costs have led to lower prices for many goods and services.
• Simplified Tax Structure: The transparency and simplicity of the GST structure have made it easier for consumers to understand the taxes they are paying, fostering trust in the tax system.

8. Enhanced Economic Growth
GST has contributed to overall economic growth by creating a more efficient and streamlined tax system:

• Formalization of the Economy: By bringing more businesses into the formal tax net, GST has increased the formalization of the economy, leading to better data collection and policy formulation.
• Increased Investment: The improved ease of doing business and the reduction in tax complexities have attracted more domestic and foreign investments, stimulating economic growth.

Drawbacks of GST in India

The introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India on July 1, 2017, marked a historic overhaul of the country’s indirect tax system. Despite its many benefits, GST has faced several criticisms and challenges. This article examines the key drawbacks of GST in India, highlighting the areas where the system has encountered issues and posed difficulties for businesses and the economy.

1. Complexity of the Tax Structure
Although GST was introduced to simplify the tax system, it has been criticized for its complexity:

• Multiple Tax Slabs: GST has multiple tax slabs (0%, 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%), which complicate the tax calculation process for businesses. Determining the correct tax rate for various goods and services can be challenging.
• Frequent Changes: The GST Council frequently revises tax rates and compliance requirements, making it difficult for businesses to stay updated and comply with the latest regulations.

2. Compliance Burden
The GST compliance process has proven to be cumbersome, especially for small and medium enterprises (SMEs):

• Multiple Returns: Businesses are required to file multiple returns, including GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, and annual returns, which increases the administrative burden.
• Technical Glitches: The GST Network (GSTN) portal has faced numerous technical issues, causing delays and frustration for taxpayers attempting to file returns and make payments.

3. Impact on Small Businesses
Small businesses have faced several challenges under the GST regime:

• High Compliance Costs: The cost of complying with GST, including accounting software and professional fees, is relatively high for small businesses.
• Working Capital Strain: The requirement to pay GST at the time of supply, irrespective of when payment is received, has strained the working capital of small businesses, especially those operating on thin margins.

4. Economic Slowdown
The introduction of GST has been linked to an economic slowdown in certain sectors:

• Disruption of Supply Chains: The initial rollout of GST disrupted supply chains and caused temporary business slowdowns as companies adjusted to the new tax system.
• Impact on Unorganized Sector: The unorganized sector, which forms a significant part of the Indian economy, has been adversely affected due to the compliance requirements and formalization pressures of GST.

5. Issues with Input Tax Credit (ITC)
The mechanism for claiming ITC under GST has faced several issues:

• Mismatch Problems: There have been frequent mismatches between the supplier’s and recipient’s invoices, leading to denial of ITC claims.
• Restrictions on ITC: The government has imposed various restrictions on ITC claims to curb fraud, but these restrictions have added to the complexity and compliance burden for genuine taxpayers.

6. State Revenues and Compensation
The impact of GST on state revenues has been a contentious issue:

• Revenue Shortfall: Several states have experienced revenue shortfalls post-GST implementation, leading to concerns about the adequacy of the GST compensation mechanism.
• Delay in Compensation: Delays in the disbursement of compensation to states by the central government have created financial stress for state governments, affecting their ability to fund developmental projects.

7. Lack of Awareness and Training
The GST regime has highlighted the lack of awareness and training among businesses:

• Insufficient Training Programs: Many small businesses and traders have not received adequate training on GST compliance, leading to errors and penalties.
• Awareness Campaigns: Despite efforts by the government, there remains a significant portion of the business community that is not fully aware of the intricacies of GST.

8. Sector-Specific Issues
Certain sectors have faced specific challenges under the GST regime:

• Real Estate: The real estate sector has faced confusion regarding the applicability of GST on under-construction properties and the treatment of land and development rights.
• Textiles: The textile industry, which predominantly comprises small and unorganized players, has struggled with the compliance requirements of GST, impacting their operations.

Conclusion
The implementation of GST in India has brought numerous benefits, including the simplification of the tax structure, reduction in the cascading effect of taxes, increased transparency and compliance, boost to revenue collection, ease of doing business, encouragement of the Make in India initiative, increased consumer welfare, and enhanced economic growth. However, it has also faced challenges such as complexity, compliance burden, economic impact on small businesses, and sector-specific issues. The various amendments and ongoing reforms reflect the government's commitment to creating a robust and taxpayer-friendly system. Continuous efforts to simplify procedures, improve the GSTN infrastructure, and provide adequate support to businesses are essential to mitigate the drawbacks and ensure the long-term success of the GST regime in India.

Share this News