In a significant move, the Supreme Court vacation bench has made a remarkable decision to uphold transparency and equal opportunity by refusing to allow senior counsels to mention or argue cases during the summer break. Justices Vikram Nath and Ahsanuddin Amanullah, the dynamic duo at the helm of this bench, firmly stated that instructing counsel or advocates-on-record (AoRs) should be given the chance to present their arguments.

Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi and others were promptly redirected to their respective AoRs to handle the mentioning, thereby promoting fairness in the judicial process. The bench's resolute stance was evident when senior counsel Anjana Prakash attempted to present a case, only to be met with a courteous but firm refusal. The bench made it clear that they would hear the counsel next to her instead.

While senior advocate Siddhartha Dave tried to highlight the differing practices of other vacation benches, Justice Nath reasserted the bench's principle, declaring that they would not allow seniors to argue during vacations. Justice Amanullah emphasized the transparency with which the bench was implementing this rule.

Interestingly, the bench's approach diverges from that of other vacation benches within the Supreme Court, which have granted senior counsels the opportunity to argue in specific matters, particularly those related to bail and transfer petitions. However, the present bench, led by Justices Nath and Amanullah, remains steadfast in its resolve to ensure fair and equal treatment for all.

The bench's commitment to maintaining consistency and avoiding any perception of discrimination was highlighted during a bail case when senior advocate Siddharth Luthra offered his assistance. However, Justice Nath cautioned against setting a precedent that might imply preferential treatment, emphasizing the bench's determination to avoid any such situation.

Former Chief Justice of India, NV Ramana, also discouraged senior counsels from making mentionings before him, underscoring the importance of the mentioning officer's role in preventing senior advocates from receiving preferential treatment.

By empowering advocates-on-record and promoting a level playing field, the Supreme Court vacation bench, headed by Justices Nath and Amanullah, reaffirms the judiciary's commitment to fairness and transparency.