The landmark Vishakha case, decided by the Supreme Court of India in 1997, set a precedent for addressing sexual harassment at the workplace. This case arose from a brutal incident of gang-rape suffered by Bhanwari Devi, a social worker in Rajasthan, which highlighted the need for a legal framework to protect women from sexual harassment at work. The Supreme Court's judgment laid down comprehensive guidelines, known as the Vishakha Guidelines, which mandated the establishment of mechanisms to prevent and redress sexual harassment at all workplaces. These guidelines remained the primary standard until the enactment of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act in 2013.

Implementation and Enforcement of the Vishakha Guidelines

Initially, the implementation of the Vishakha Guidelines was uneven and inconsistent across various sectors. Many organizations were either unaware of the guidelines or chose to ignore them due to the lack of a concrete enforcement mechanism. However, several public interest litigations and increased activism from women's rights organizations led to a gradual but significant shift.

1. Corporate Sector Response: Larger corporations and multinational companies were quicker to adopt the Vishakha Guidelines, integrating them into their corporate policies. They established Internal Complaints Committees (ICCs) and conducted awareness programs for employees.

2. Public Sector and Government Compliance: Government departments and public sector undertakings began to set up complaints committees and frame their own sexual harassment policies. However, the pace of implementation varied significantly across different states and departments.

3. Educational Institutions: Universities and colleges also began setting up complaints committees. The University Grants Commission (UGC) played a vital role by issuing directives to ensure compliance with the guidelines.

Legislative Developments: The 2013 Act

The enactment of the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act in 2013 was a significant milestone. This Act codified the Vishakha Guidelines into law, providing a clear legal framework and making it mandatory for all employers to adhere to its provisions. Key features of the Act include:

- Definition of Sexual Harassment: The Act provides a comprehensive definition of sexual harassment, including physical contact, advances, demand or request for sexual favors, sexually colored remarks, showing pornography, and any other unwelcome physical, verbal, or non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature.

- Internal Complaints Committee (ICC): Every employer with more than ten employees must constitute an ICC to address complaints of sexual harassment. The ICC must include a senior female employee, two members from the workforce, and an external member familiar with issues relating to sexual harassment.

- Local Complaints Committee (LCC): For workplaces with fewer than ten employees or where the complaint is against the employer, a Local Complaints Committee must be established at the district level.

- Penalties and Compensation: The Act provides for penalties against employers who fail to comply with its provisions and includes measures for compensating the aggrieved woman.

Challenges and Persistent Issues

Despite the progress made, several challenges persist in the effective implementation of the law:

1. Awareness and Training: Many organizations still lack adequate awareness and training programs. This results in a lack of understanding of what constitutes sexual harassment and the processes for addressing it.

2. Underreporting: Fear of retaliation, stigma, and a lack of trust in the redressal mechanisms lead to significant underreporting of incidents. Victims often prefer to remain silent rather than face potential career setbacks or public scrutiny.

3. Effectiveness of ICCs and LCCs: The functioning of ICCs and LCCs varies widely. In some cases, committees are not constituted as per the guidelines, and their proceedings lack transparency and impartiality. External members are sometimes not adequately trained or experienced.

4. Small and Informal Workplaces: Compliance in small and informal workplaces remains a major issue. Many small businesses and informal sector employers are either unaware of the law or choose to ignore it, leaving many women unprotected.

5. Judicial Backlog: Cases of sexual harassment often face delays in the judicial system, leading to prolonged trauma for the victims and delayed justice.

The Way Forward

To build on the progress made since the Vishakha case, concerted efforts are needed to address the existing gaps and challenges:

- Enhanced Awareness Campaigns: There is a need for sustained awareness campaigns to educate employers and employees about the law, their rights, and the processes available for redressal.

- Regular Training: Organizations should conduct regular training sessions for all employees, especially those involved in the functioning of ICCs and LCCs, to ensure they are equipped to handle complaints effectively and sensitively.

- Strengthening Redressal Mechanisms: Ensuring that ICCs and LCCs function impartially and transparently is crucial. This includes proper selection of members, regular audits, and feedback mechanisms to improve their effectiveness.

- Support for Victims: Providing support services such as counseling, legal aid, and protection against retaliation can encourage more victims to come forward and report incidents of harassment.

- Focus on Informal Sector: Special attention should be given to implementing the law in the informal sector, with targeted interventions and support to ensure that all women, regardless of their employment status, are protected.

The Vishakha case and the subsequent legislative framework have undoubtedly been instrumental in addressing workplace sexual harassment in India. However, continued vigilance, advocacy, and reforms are essential to ensure that the promise of a safe and respectful workplace for all women is fully realized.

Share this News